The chemical, microstructural, and fractographic analyses provide information on the material science aspects of the failure. In table 4 the failure rate for both pump are shown. An analysis was made to identify the causes of vibration and failure problems with the piping and reciprocating pump internals on an oil pipeline station. The failure analysis report provides a permanent record of the failure, the analysis to identify its causes, and required corrective actions. Ratchet marks found in the large fatigue portion, and originating from the surface of the rod body, completely encircle the fracture surface with the small tensile. It is important to consider not only the pump itself during failure analysis, but also what exactly is being pumped.
It provides expert analysis and insight on a variety of materials, failure modes, root causes, and analytical techniques. Fatigue failure analysis of a centrifugal pump shaft. Pump failure analysis as there are only a few symptoms with which to recognize a troubled pump, the key to failure analysis lies in understanding how the combinations of symptoms identify the underlying cause of the problem. Failure of the duct is been observed in expansion joints. Handbook of case histories in failure analysis failure.
Decrease of torque capacity of interference connection is responsible for the failure. Applied technical services offers pump failure analysis for various systems and industries. Root cause ac motor failure analysis with a focus on shaft. A survey was conducted among the three categories of pump users namely domestic, agricultural. Hydraulic gear pump and motor failure analysis and repair guide. Centrifugal pumps are common process plant equipment and here is a useful list of pump failure modes to understand what can cause centrifugal pumps to fail.
Impeller looseness failure occurred at centrifugal pump normal rated condition. Mechanical seals account for 44 % of pump repair costs. Global failure rate pump failure rate fh pump a 0,000281128 pump b 0,000169465 applying equation 5 to calculate the reliability value for the ngl centrifugal pump system at two years for non. Pdf fatigue failure analysis of a centrifugal pump shaft. Often a large number of factors, frequently interrelated, must be understood to determine the cause of the original, or primary, failure. In the following, examples of common causes of failure of mechanical shaft seals will be discussed. Collection and analysis of commoncause failures of centrifugal pumps.
This failure analysis guide is intended to give a general outline of common failure modes of progressing cavity pumping systems along with their respective root causes and possible solutions. The mechanical design analyses establish the cause of. The importance and value of failure analysis to safety, reliability, performance, and economy are well documented. In fact, while wilbur was traveling in france in 1908, orville was. The discipline of failure analysis has evolved and matured, as it has been employed and formalized as a means for failure prevention. Ats failure analysis capabilities include identifying design flaws, material makeup, assembly or fabrication defects, and improper installation or use in determining a root cause. Although a complete system analysis is beyond the scope of this paper, when conducting a root cause failure analysis, it is important to recognize that the motor is only one component of a system. The pump service database is a valuable asset to this effort. For example, the importance of investigating failures is vividly illustrated in the pioneering efforts of the wright brothers in developing selfpropelled flight. Unexpected failure of the pumps become more costly due to the interruption in. This volume examines more than 100 cases of failure and the process by which they were analyzed, diagnosed, and resolved.
This article briefly introduces the concepts of failure analysis, rootcause analysis, and the role of failure analysis as a general engineering tool for enhancing product quality and failure prevention. Weibull analysis of time between failures of pumps used in an oil refinery vol. In the context of pumps, the term cavitation implies a dynamic process of formation of bubbles inside the liquid, their growth and subsequent collapse as. The procedures are demonstrated in performing failure analysis of a centrifugal pump shaft. The study of failure analysis of centrifugal pump on the. I took all the failure causes for each failure mode off the internet by doing a web. A pump fmea approach to improve reliability centered. This chapter deliberates on the systematic processes in failure investigation of engineering components and structures. Certain dewatering pumps are designed with high chrome or urethanelined components to handle abrasive solids, while other wastewater pumps are designed for pumping soft, compressible solids using simpler cast iron components. Mechanical seals account for 39 % of pump failures. Hydraulic gear pump and motor failure analysis and repair guide page 2 of 32 alamo industrial 1502 e walnut st, seguin, tx 78155. Are you experiencing piston ring failure, but arent sure what might have caused it. Major failure modes of centrifugal pumps since centrifugal pumps are one of the worlds most widely used type of pump, their operational parameters and also their vulnerabilities are well known. A detailed well history can benefit the operator directly.
Maintenance and troubleshooting of progressing cavity pumps. Root cause analysis of five costly centrifugal pump failures by. The lists in the spreadsheet were put together by researching the web for centrifugal pump failure causes, including failure modes of components in the wetend, the bearing housing, the drive coupling, the electric drive motor and the base with foundations. Citescore values are based on citation counts in a given year e. Failure analysis what is cavitation and how can i tell if my pump is cavitating. Seals and bearings are essentially nonrepairable items and will also be discussed separately. Identify pump failure problems with root cause analysis. Rod box or body failures due to corrosion around all of the tubing circumference. Failures of the front pump are, in fact, limited to just a few specific modes such as overheating, overpressurization, shaft failures, contamination and cavitation. Typical failure modes of centrifugal pump assemblies. Collection and analysis of commoncause failures of centrifugal pumps october 2012 jt03342760 complete document available on olis in its original format this document and any map included herein are without prejudice to the status of or sovereignty over any territory, to the deli mitation of. Remember, the hydraulic pump is generally the most expensive component on a hydraulic system.
Contact pressure and torque capacity of interference connection are evaluated by fem. The example shown in 1a is a torsional fatigue failure from a progressing cavity pump. Problems at the faces carbons, ceramic, silicon and tungsten carbide faces wear heat hangup. Hydraulic gear pump and motor failure analysis and repair guide page 10 of 32 alamo industrial 1502 e walnut st, seguin, tx 78155.
However, it can also be used to benefit other members of the failure analysis team. Turbocharger failure analysis is a science unto itself. Collection and analysis of commoncause failures of centrifugal pumps october 2012 jt03342760 complete document available on olis in its original format this document and any map included herein are without prejudice to the status. In this paper, the studies of failure analysis centrifugal pump from the perspective life its components and frequency occurrence of failure in it has done. Turbos are applied to everything from commercial diesels to street performance vehicles and professional competition vehicles. Failure analysis of centrifugal pump impeller sciencedirect.
In order to properly understand some of the failure modes covered herein and their respective root causes. Pdf hydraulic gear pump and motor failure analysis and. Knowing a pumps bep is critical in the forensic process of pump failure analysis only through pressure readings of the system or calculations of an applications piping system can one determine this duty point. One of the values of this section for the turbo enthusiast or. Problems with secondary seals orings, bellows cuts overheated compatibility with process. They have a significant impact on environmental compliance, product quality, mission assurance.
Sleeve of the expansion joint is failing and because of these failures, bellows directly exposed to hot gases also fails. Microstructure and mechanical property of impeller are tested and used in analysis. In summary, cavitation is an abnormal condition that can result in loss of production, and equipment damage. Be careful not to bend or score the plate and mating surface of the casting. Mckee, gareth forbes, ilyas mazhar, rodney entwistle and ian howard curtin university, western australia summary. Analysis of vibration and failure problems in reciprocating. This failure analysis takes you through possible issues that may have caused your piston rings.
Failure analysis in study of any failure, the analyst must consider a broad spectrum of possibilities or reasons for the occurrence. Methodology analysis of data failure of centrifugal pump. Major failure modes of centrifugal pumps nuclear power. In other words, when the pump starts to fail, it starts to kick out debris into a debris field downstream of the pump. But more important is to understand how pump failure modes arise and what to do to remove the pump failure root causes.
Failure mode effect and criticality analysis reputed manufacturing company type of failures symptoms no functional failure liquid delivered not enough liquid delivered 2. Innovative fluid power1 failure analysis a guide to analyzing axial piston pump failures oilgear company milwaukee, usa 80776, rev. Tn vickers pump failure analysis how to read clues in hydraulic vane and piston pumps to learn what really caused them to fal table of. Since centrifugal pumps are one of the worlds most widely used type of pump, their operational parameters and also their vulnerabilities are well known. Collection and analysis of commoncause failures of centrifugal. This report describes the analysis carried out to investigate the causes of failure using fea package and analytical method. Included are sections dedicated to specific components, industries, and other factors in transportation and motive power systems, buildings and bridges, petrochemicalchemical processing, mining and manufacturing, mechanical. How to read clues in hydraulic vane and piston pumps to learn what really caused them to fail. Recording systems failure analysis results is important for several reasons.
Fatigue failure analysis of a centrifugal pump shaft intechopen. Pdf on nov 15, 2017, abdelrady okasha elnady and others published fault analysis of the a4vso axial piston pump find, read and cite all the research you need on researchgate. A field investigation was made to obtain vibrations and pulsations over the entire range of plant operating conditions. It has the highest reliability risk, the highest contaminant sensitivity risk and the ability to cause chainreaction failures. This study is a maiden attempt to conduct failure analysis of a centrifugal pump from the perspective of life of its components and frequency of occurrence of problems in it. The pump fmea in the form of linguistic variables and semiotic signs failure mode. Some pump manufacturers will have engineers inhouse who can create a performance report to assist customers in determining. A wellwritten failure analysis report details the results of the failure analysis, and it defines required corrective actions. The failure mode and effect analysis fmea process the fmea methodology is based on a hierarchical, inductive approach to analysis.
Many factors affecting the system will also affect the motor and may contribute to the motor failure and vice versa. There are several issues that might lead to your piston rings failing, so its important to properly diagnose the issue to correct it. The best way of using the handbook and estimating the failure rate of a mechanical seal is use of the failure mode, effects and criticality analysis fmeca. Most downloaded engineering failure analysis articles. Centrifugal pumps are one of the worlds most widely used type of pump, having an extensive. Pdf on dec 20, 2017, mohd nasir tamin and others published fatigue failure analysis of a centrifugal pump shaft find, read and cite all the research you. A mechanical seal will normally be a component part of a pump, compressor or other system component at a higher indenture level. Study of centrifugal pump using failure mode effect and. Half of a plants maintenance budget is very often spent on pumps, and pumps are commonly the single largest source of unplanned downtime.
855 1173 765 654 689 368 394 1559 168 1053 431 703 1464 970 670 383 330 671 1199 1256 115 971 620 1086 1016 356 845 539 202 1417 654 1476 1364 874 1416 1096 564 314 152 916 501 176 1463